Toward a Theory of Culturally Relevant Pedagogy

In this episode I unpack Ladson-Billings’ (1995) seminal publication titled “Toward a theory of culturally relevant pedagogy,” which influenced much of the discourse around culturally relevant pedagogy in computer science education.

  • Welcome back to another episode of the

    CSK8 podcast my name is jared o'leary

    in this week's episode i'm going to

    unpack the paper titled toward a theory

    of culturally relevant pedagogy

    by gloria ladson billings but before i

    do that i want to give a quick shout out

    to

    the username ms b tech who left a review

    on apple podcast

    thank you so much for your kind review

    it really does mean a lot to me and

    please let me know if there's anything i

    can do

    to use my power and privilege to help

    you now i'm not going to read the review

    out loud because i think it's weird when

    podcast hosts do that

    i don't know why they do it to be honest

    if someone wants to explain it to me

    please let me know

    anyways thank you ms b tech so today's

    episode is going to discuss the seminal

    paper

    that launched the culturally relevant

    pedagogy movement

    i've previously talked about crp in

    other episodes

    such as the episode where i unpacked the

    scratch encore curriculum

    or at least the paper about it however

    this is

    a paper that was written in 1995 for the

    american educational research journal

    and it is the seminal paper on this

    topic so we're going straight to the

    source here

    even though it's multiple decades old it

    is very relevant today especially at the

    time that this is being released

    now what's nice is the link in the show

    notes

    which can be found in the app that

    you're listening to this on or by

    visiting jaredlery.com

    if you click on the paper title you can

    go straight to the paper and read it

    off for free in a pdf form and if you

    click on the author's last name

    then it'll take you to her google

    scholar profile where you can read

    many more works written by gloria ladson

    billings

    okay so here's the abstract for the

    paper

    quote in the midst of discussions about

    improving education

    teacher education equity and diversity

    little has been done to make pedagogy a

    central area of investigation

    this article attempts to challenge

    notions about the intersection of

    culture

    and teaching that relies solely on

    microanalytic or macroanalytic

    perspectives

    rather the article attempts to build on

    the work done in both of these areas and

    proposes a culturally relevant theory of

    education

    by raising questions about the location

    of the researcher and pedagogical

    research

    the article attempts to explicate the

    theoretical framework for the author and

    the nexus of collaborative and reflexive

    research

    the pedagogical practices of eight

    exemplary teachers of african american

    students

    serve as the investigative site their

    practices and reflections

    on those practices provide a way to

    define and recognize culturally relevant

    pedagogy

    end quote so the publication itself is

    actually guided around some of the

    following questions which are on page

    quote what constitutes student success

    how can academic success and cultural

    success

    complement each other in settings where

    student alienation and hostility

    characterize the school experience

    how can pedagogy promote the kind of

    student success that engages larger

    social structural issues in a critical

    way how do researchers recognize that

    pedagogy

    in action and what are the implications

    for teacher preparation generated by

    this pedagogy end quote

    so if i were to summarize this paper

    into a single sentence i'd say that this

    paper outlines the origins of culturally

    relevant pedagogy

    it provides examples of what culturally

    relevant pedagogy looks like in practice

    and it unpacks culturally relevant

    pedagogy in relation to self and other

    social relations and knowledge in the

    classroom now you may have gathered this

    from hearing

    the abstract that this is written for

    teacher educators so academics scholars

    if you're not used to reading academic

    discourse on pedagogical theories

    perhaps listen to this episode and watch

    the webinar linked in the show notes

    where

    gloria ladson billings discusses crp in

    relation to schooling in the times of

    covid

    and then after you've kind of gone

    through those two things i highly

    recommend coming back to this paper and

    reading the paper itself

    because there's a lot of great content

    in there that i really think all

    educators

    should take some time to read through

    okay so this paper begins with a short

    description

    of different approaches at that time

    again 1995

    such as culturally appropriate

    culturally congruent

    and culturally compatible teaching some

    of the example studies incorporated like

    hawaiian and native american cultures

    within their respective communities

    and it resulted in an increase in

    standardized tests and general academic

    performance

    here's a quote from page 467 quote by

    observing the students in their home

    community environment teachers were able

    to include aspects of students

    cultural environment in the organization

    and instruction of the classroom

    end quote so in times of covid we might

    think about how

    might we use our ability to see a little

    bit more about a kid's home life

    to learn more about them as individuals

    and the cultures that they are a part of

    now that being said the author mentions

    that culturally appropriate culturally

    congruent and culturally compatible

    teaching

    quote have several common features each

    locates the source of student failure

    and subsequent achievement within the

    nexus of speech and language interaction

    patterns of the teacher and the students

    each suggests the student's success

    quote

    is represented in achievement within the

    current social structures

    extend in schools thus the goal of

    education becomes how to quote

    fit students constructed as quote other

    by virtue of the race ethnicity language

    or social class into a hierarchical

    structure that is defined as a

    meritocracy

    however it is unclear how these

    conceptions do more than reproduce the

    current inequalities

    end quote so one way that we might

    describe this is it's kind of the

    assimilation approach so you're going

    we're going to start with your culture

    and we're going to simulate

    you into our culture which can position

    things as a right and wrong so like

    the way that you're doing things is not

    correct so we're going to make you do

    things our way

    now lats in billings refers to

    pedagogy's quote that not only address

    student achievement but also helps

    students to accept and affirm the

    cultural identity

    while developing critical perspectives

    that challenge any qualities that

    schools

    and other institutions perpetuate in

    quote from page 469

    she refers to those as culturally

    relevant pedagogy

    so in the next section the author

    mentions that there's this illusion

    around theory in that even if you think

    you're not explicitly operating

    under a particular educational or

    pedagogical theory

    you are so as a result we should try and

    actively

    explore how these various educational

    theories are informing our own practices

    to better understand

    why we are doing what we are doing so in

    particular we can think of

    epistemologies which are like our ways

    of knowing

    and learning we can look at ontologies

    which are like our ways of being

    and we can look at axiologies so our

    ways of valuing

    so if we look at those three things and

    obviously others

    this can give you a pretty good idea of

    how different theories are

    impacting your understanding of what we

    know

    what we are doing or are

    and what we value okay so crp was

    actually developed

    out of working quote with a group of

    eight teachers

    in a small less than three thousand

    students predominantly african-american

    low-income elementary school district in

    northern california end quote

    from page 471 teachers have between

    quote

    most of it with african-american

    students

    end quote that's from page 473 and the

    study itself

    had four phases to it so the first phase

    was interviewing the teachers

    the next phase was an average of three

    observations each week over a two year

    period

    which is a very long period for

    educational studies

    and then phase three was kind of

    overlapping with phase two and it was

    videotaping these observations and then

    phase four was actually having the

    teachers watch each other's video tapes

    and engaging in

    ten meetings of two to three hours each

    to discuss each teacher's quote

    analysis and interpretation of their own

    and one another's practice

    end quote from page 472

    in addition latin billings began looking

    for expert teachers by asking parents

    for examples of

    exemplary teaching then would meet with

    a group of these teachers to kind of

    discuss their approaches

    so through these discussions they talked

    about a variety of topics now one of the

    things that's really interesting

    is when it came to common threads around

    caring for students

    they focused on quote the implications

    of the work had on their students lives

    the welfare of the community

    and unjust social arrangements thus

    rather than

    the idiosyncratic caring for individual

    students for whom they did seem to care

    the teachers spoke of the import of

    their work for preparing the students

    for confronting

    inequitable and undemocratic social

    structures

    end quote from page 474 so in other

    words

    teachers were really focused on helping

    kids

    and situating their learning within the

    health and welfare of the community

    while also discussing unjust social

    arrangements

    which we'll talk about later in this

    episode now one of the interesting

    quotes about this is how teachers

    responded to

    practices that they disagreed with so

    here's a quote from page 474

    quote the teachers demonstrated this

    ethic of personal accountability in the

    kind of pedagogical stands they took

    several of the teachers spoke of defying

    administrative mandates in order to do

    what they believe was right for students

    others gave examples of proactive

    actions they took to engage in

    pedagogical practices

    more consistent with their beliefs and

    values for example

    one teacher was convinced that the

    school district's mandated reading

    program

    was inconsistent with what she was

    learning about literacy

    teaching learning from a critical

    perspective she decided to write a

    proposal

    to the school board asking for

    experimental status

    for literacy approach she wanted to use

    in her classroom

    her proposal was buttressed by current

    research and literacy

    and would not cost the district any more

    than the proposed program

    ultimately she was granted permission to

    conduct her experiment

    and its success allowed other teachers

    to attempt it in subsequent years

    end quote i love this approach however

    i want to point out that the more

    cultural capital that you have

    and the more that you can cite research

    the better

    and by cultural capital i mean like the

    things that are valued within your

    school in terms of making you

    appear as an expert in the eyes of other

    administrators or school board members

    or whatever

    so for instance years teaching in the

    classroom advanced degrees things like

    that are all forms of cultural capital

    so are like teaching awards and parent

    reviews

    things like that now if you don't have

    that kind of cultural capital one of the

    things that i recommend is pointing

    towards other people in particular other

    researchers and scholars

    who do have some capital that you can

    cite or use

    to assist with experimenting with

    different approaches

    so for example i don't go by dr o'leary

    unless i'm encouraging someone to use my

    title

    to assert a claim that supports

    something that they are actually

    fighting for

    and that i've also stated during like a

    presentation or publication

    so for example if i say something in

    this podcast that's based on research

    and that you agree with and you really

    want to try in the classroom and then

    you have an administrator that's like

    yeah i don't really know about that idea

    you can be like well

    actually dr o'leary says blah blah

    because of

    blah blah research and then that often

    times is enough cultural capital to

    at least let an administrator listen to

    what you're talking about sometimes

    okay so that's kind of what led to the

    development of this

    theory so now we're going to actually

    talk about the three main areas

    so the theory of culturally relevant

    pedagogy seeks to quote

    produce students who can achieve

    academically

    produce students who demonstrate

    cultural competence and develop students

    who can both understand and critique the

    existing social order

    end quote that's from page 474

    so in other words there are three main

    areas academic achievement

    cultural competence and critique so

    we're going to unpack all of those

    now in her study and other studies that

    she has cited lads and billings mentions

    that

    students achieved academically this is

    important to note because some people

    think that this is a watering down of a

    curriculum or students are

    unable to achieve if you're deviating

    from what is

    typically done in a classroom setting or

    what a curriculum it recommends

    however lads and billings insist that

    quote culturally relevant pedagogy must

    provide a way for students to maintain

    their cultural integrity while

    succeeding academically end quote

    from page 476 so it's not just learning

    about a culture or incorporating it into

    a classroom

    it's succeeding academically while

    maintaining cultural integrity so here

    are some examples

    of how this was done so exploring poetry

    through rap

    lyrics encouraging a student who took a

    lot of pride in their cultural

    background

    but got in a lot of trouble through

    those expressions of their cultural

    background to actually run

    for sixth grade president which he won

    and then a third example that

    is given is encouraging kids to take on

    the role of academic leaders

    so here's a quote from page 476 quote

    their academic leadership allowed their

    cultural values and styles to be

    appreciated

    and affirmed because these

    african-american male students were

    permitted

    indeed encouraged to be themselves in

    dress language style

    and interaction styles while achieving

    in school the other students who

    regarded them highly

    because of their popularity were able to

    see academic engagement as cool

    end quote so in other words the first

    area academic achievement

    kids need to succeed academically and

    two cultural competence

    go hand in hand in that you can

    integrate cultural competence

    in a way that supports academic

    achievement

    okay so now the third major point of

    crp is the critique specifically

    critiquing the existing social order

    so lads and billings notes that quote

    not only must teachers encourage

    academic success and cultural competence

    it must help students to recognize

    understand and critique

    current social inequities this notion

    presumes that teachers themselves

    recognize social inequalities and their

    causes however

    teacher educators have demonstrated that

    many prospective teachers

    not only lack these understandings but

    reject information regarding social

    inequity

    end quote as from pages 476 to 477

    now if you're unfamiliar with some of

    the social inequalities around race

    check out the show notes from the i

    can't breathe unpacking scholarship

    episode

    that i released a few episodes ago

    you'll literally find hundreds of

    resources and suggestions of where to

    learn more

    and upcoming podcasts are also going to

    have more resources

    and scholarship and interviews etc to

    further unpack this

    okay so what are some examples that were

    provided of critiquing existing social

    order

    right now we can probably think of

    several off the top of our heads in

    terms of

    what i just mentioned with the i can't

    breathe movement with what happened with

    george floyd with

    the countless other people who have been

    systematically

    oppressed or violently murdered but here

    are a couple of examples from the

    publication itself

    in relation to what teachers did in the

    classroom

    so here's a quote from page 477 quote

    one teacher worked with her students to

    identify poorly utilized space in the

    community

    examine heretofore inaccessible archival

    records about the early history of the

    community

    plan alternative uses for a vacant

    shopping mall

    and write urban plans which they

    presented before the city council

    end quote as another example from middle

    school kids in dallas texas

    quote zoning regulations in the city

    made some areas dry

    while the student's school was in a wet

    area

    the students identified the fact that

    schools serving white

    upper middle class students were located

    in dry areas while schools in poor

    communities were in wet areas

    the students assisted by their teacher

    planned a strategy for exposing this

    inequality

    by using mathematics literacy social and

    political skills

    the students were able to prove their

    points with reports

    editorials charts maps and graphs

    in both of these examples teachers

    allowed students to use their community

    circumstance as

    official knowledge their pedagogy and

    the student's learning

    became a form of cultural critique end

    quote from page 477

    i hope all you are listening to that

    particular quote you were thinking of

    the potential for computer science in

    that scenario for example as

    data analysis or data representation

    very easily able to integrate computer

    science

    into a project like that and connect it

    with other subject areas

    okay so quick summary so we have

    academic achievement cultural competence

    and critique of existing social orders

    those are the three main pillars if you

    will

    of culturally relevant pedagogy and

    we kind of talked about some examples of

    them now all three of those things

    have been discussed in previous episodes

    in terms of we want kids to be

    successful academically and in life

    we want kids to be able to bring their

    own interests or cultures into what they

    do

    and then we've had some guests who have

    talked about different critiques some of

    the upcoming interviews that are going

    to be released we'll

    dive into that a little bit more the

    third pillar critiques of existing

    social orders

    so stay tuned for more episodes related

    to that

    okay so now we're going to talk about

    some of the pedagogies that were used

    and these pedagogies were around three

    broad propositions

    and they are quote the conceptions of

    self and other held by culturally

    relevant teachers

    the manner in which social relations are

    structured by culturally relevant

    teachers

    the concepts of knowledge held by

    culturally relevant teachers end quote

    so we have the conceptions of ourself

    and others social relations

    and conceptions of knowledge so let's

    unpack each of those

    so regarding teachers conceptions of

    self and others

    teachers quote believed that all these

    students were capable of academic

    success

    saw their pedagogy as art unpredictable

    always in the process of becoming

    saw themselves as members of the

    community saw teaching as a way to give

    back to the community

    believed in the freyrian notion of

    teaching as mining or pulling knowledge

    out

    in quote thus from pages 478-479

    now i'll talk about paulo freyr in a

    future episode

    or we'll unpack pedagogy of the

    oppressed but that's down the road

    now if you're listening to that and are

    thinking okay that just sounds like good

    teaching

    lads and billings has an excellent quote

    that i'll read to you at the very end so

    stay tuned

    for the end of this episode okay so

    here's another quote that's important to

    point out this is page 479

    quote absent from their discourse about

    students was the language of lacking

    students were never referred to as being

    from a single parent household

    being on afdc welfare or needing

    psychological

    evaluation instead teachers talked about

    their own shortcomings and limitations

    and ways they needed to change to ensure

    student success

    in quote i love that quote especially

    that last sentence about

    being open with your own shortcomings

    and limitations as an educator

    and explaining how you're continuing to

    learn and grow to try and help the kids

    that you're working with

    many of the guests have reiterated

    similar notions

    off the top of my head in particular the

    interview with katie henry and the

    interview with bob irving

    we talk about stuff like this here's

    another important quote related to

    conceptions of self and others that's

    also from page 479

    quote the teachers made conscious

    decisions to be a part of the community

    from which their students come

    three of the eight teachers in this

    study live in the school community

    the others made deliberate efforts to

    come to this community for goods

    services and leisure activities

    demonstrating their belief in the

    community as an

    important and worthwhile place in both

    their lives and the lives of their

    students

    end quote this is very important it's

    important because it helps with

    preventing teachers from seeming like an

    other

    as an outsider if there are ways that

    you can connect with your community

    members

    in the schools that you're working with

    if you live close enough to do that or

    within the community

    there's some great suggestions in here

    in terms of thinking through

    how you can be known and just know and

    learn from the communities in which you

    work with

    okay so let's talk about the second

    broad proposition which has to do with

    social relations

    so teachers quote maintain fluid student

    teacher relationships

    demonstrate a connectedness with all of

    the students

    develop a community of learners

    encourage students to learn

    collaboratively and be responsible for

    another end quote so an example of this

    that's pointed out by lats and billings

    is that

    kids had the opportunity to teach and

    learn from each other

    this was encouraged by the teachers in

    fact it was encouraged by all

    of the teachers so lads and billings in

    particular on page 480 mentions quote

    all of the students were made aware that

    they were expected to excel at something

    and that the teacher would call on them

    to share that expertise with classmates

    the culturally relevant teachers

    encourage community of learners rather

    than competitive

    individual achievement by demanding a

    higher level of academic success for the

    entire class

    individual success did not suffer

    however

    rather than lifting up individuals and

    perhaps

    contributing to feelings of pure

    alienation the teachers made it clear

    that they were working with smart

    classes

    for many of the students this

    identification with academic success was

    a new experience

    end quote i love this quote but based on

    more research related to like fixed and

    growth mindsets

    rather than saying that a class is smart

    which would be more along the fixed

    mindset for

    those of you who have read carol dweck's

    stuff i would argue that we should

    instead say

    that the classes are putting in a lot of

    effort toward their own learning rather

    than saying that they're smart

    and perhaps i'll do an episode that kind

    of unpacks carol dweck's notion of

    fixed versus growth mindset if that's

    not familiar with

    this audience although it's kind of

    become buzzwords so

    likely you are so here's an example from

    page 481

    that kind of contextualizes things quote

    one teacher used a buddy system

    where each student was paired with

    another the buddies checked each other's

    homework and class assignments

    buddies quiz each other for tests and if

    one buddy was absent it was the

    responsibility of the other to call cy

    and to help with makeup work the

    teachers used this ethos

    of reciprocity and mutuality to insist

    that one person's success

    was the success of all and one person's

    failure

    was the failure of all these feelings

    were exemplified by the teacher who

    insisted

    quote we're a family we have to care for

    one another

    as if one survival depended on it

    actually it does

    end quote page 41. so i don't know about

    you but when i first read that quote i

    thought it was very similar to paired

    programming but it dives deeper into the

    accountability over

    one long term and two both

    accountability inside and outside the

    classroom so if a kid is absent then

    having their partner work with him

    reach out to them figure out how they

    can help them outside of

    school which i think is really neat okay

    so those are some of the examples and

    suggestions for

    the second broad proposition regarding

    social relations so now the last one

    which is regarding

    conceptions of knowledge so teachers

    believed that

    quote knowledge is not static it is

    shared

    recycled and constructed knowledge must

    be viewed critically

    teachers must be passionate about

    knowledge and learning teachers must

    scaffold or build bridges

    to facilitate learning assessment must

    be multifaceted

    incorporating multiple forms of

    excellence in quote from page 41.

    i would highly recommend listening to

    that again except some excellent advice

    all right so here's some examples so one

    example is that a teacher had students

    identify their areas of expertise early

    in the year

    they then created a list that shared

    their expertise

    with the rest of the class so that way

    kids could know who to go to when

    discussing certain topics and wanting to

    learn more about something

    and then later students actually

    presented on their expertise to the

    class

    in addition students were frequently

    encouraged to ask why so for example

    asking the question why are we learning

    this which i love

    i personally had that question a lot in

    school and honestly never really got a

    good answer

    now teachers sometimes responded by

    posing the question to the class

    or by offering quote an explanation and

    then ask

    are you satisfied with that answer if a

    student said yes

    she might say you shouldn't be just

    because i'm the teacher doesn't mean i'm

    always right

    the teacher was careful to help students

    to understand the difference between an

    intellectual challenge

    and a challenge to the authority of

    their parents thus

    just as the students were affirmed in

    their ability to code switch

    or move with facility in language

    between african-american language and a

    standard form of english

    they were supported in the attempts at

    role switching between school and home

    end quote from page 482. now this is an

    excellent point

    i strongly encourage kids to question

    what i was doing and for

    ask why i was doing stuff and to

    challenge me

    on some of my rationales whether this is

    with elementary kids or

    university students or whatever however

    i didn't do the second part which was

    making note that the way that you are

    challenging me here is different than

    the way that you

    should probably talk to your parents i

    think that's a really good point

    to point out okay so that's kind of the

    three broad propositions

    so just a very quick summary of

    culturally relevant pedagogy so one

    it requires academic achievement two it

    requires cultural competence

    three it requires a critique of some of

    the existing social orders

    and then the pedagogies that kind of

    assist this approach

    include thinking through conceptions of

    the self and other

    the social relations that you have with

    the kids and communities that you work

    in

    and then your own conceptions of the

    knowledge in relation to

    your pedagogy and the classroom now that

    you've heard more about culturally

    relevant pedagogy

    here's a quote that i was teasing

    earlier in this podcast quote

    a common question asked by practitioners

    is isn't what you describe just good

    teaching

    and while i do not deny that it is good

    teaching i pose a counter question

    why does so little of it occur in

    classrooms populated by african american

    students

    end quote page 484

    and honestly quite a mic drop to have in

    your summary

    or conclusion of a paper okay so

    one question that i have lingering

    question because i like to do these when

    unpacking scholarship always thinking of

    what if or why or how or

    etc is what can we as cs educators do

    to continue to learn more about crp and

    incorporate it into our practices

    again i mentioned that there's a webinar

    that has been recorded that i share in

    the show notes

    where gloria ladson billings kind of

    unpacks this

    in relation to today and covid and what

    these practices could potentially mean

    i highly recommend going there for some

    resources but i also recommend just

    learning more

    about crp learning more about injustices

    that are going on and then

    doing something about it i know i'm

    doing that i'm trying to i'm

    intentionally trying to learn

    and share new things each day and the

    process can be difficult at times

    but i highly recommend everyone do it

    it's definitely worth the efforts

    i hope this podcast episode teased you

    to want to go and read the article

    it is a very good article and again you

    can just click on the title

    in the show notes or the article and

    it'll take you directly to a pdf of it

    you can access it for free

    which again you can find the show notes

    in the description that you're listening

    to this on

    or by visiting jared o'leary.com only

    thing that i ask

    after having listened to this episode is

    share this with somebody else

    crp is something that we need to be

    discussing more in computer science

    education

    and i plan on unpacking more papers

    and having more interviews that discuss

    this specifically in relation to

    computer science education

    thank you so much for listening to this

    episode i hope you're all

    staying safe doing well i hope you stay

    tuned next week

    which will be an interview and then the

    following week which will be another

    unpacking scholarship episode

    hope you all have a wonderful week

Article

Ladson-Billings, G. (1995). Toward a Theory of Culturally Relevant Pedagogy. American Educational Research Journal, 32(3), 465–491.


Abstract

“In the midst of discussions about improving education, teacher education, equity, and diversity, little has been done to make pedagogy a central area of investigation. This article attempts to challenge notions about the intersection of culture and teaching that rely solely on microanalytic or macroanalytic perspectives. Rather, the article attempts to build on the work done in both of these areas and proposes a culturally relevant theory of education. By raising questions about the location of the researcher in pedagogical research, the article attempts to explicate the theoretical framework of the author in the nexus of collaborative and reflexive research. The pedagogical practices of eight exemplary teachers of African-American students serve as the investigative “site.” Their practices and reflections on those practices provide a way to define and recognize culturally relevant pedagogy.”


My One Sentence Summary

This paper outlines the origins of culturally relevant pedagogy, provides examples of what culturally relevant pedagogy looks like in practice, and unpacks culturally relevant pedagogy in relation self and other, social relations, and knowledge in the classroom.


Some Of My Lingering Questions/Thoughts

  • What can we as CS educators do to continue to learn more about CRP and incorporate it into our practices?


Resources/Links Relevant to This Episode



More Content